NGTV Guide: Thursday, September 10

It’s a very eerie evening as two otherworldly series premiere. The Winchester brothers are back for their fifth season while another pair of brothers with even more issues join us for the first time.

Vampire Diaries – the CW 8/7c
“Pilot” – In the series opener, Virginia high-schooler Elena (Nina Dobrev) falls for a new student (Paul Wesley), who is actually a centuries-old vampire struggling to live peacefully among humans. Their budding relationship is threatened when his evil vampire brother arrives in town and tries to capture Elena’s heart for himself.

Supernatural – the CW 9/8c
“Sympathy for the Devil” – The fifth season begins with Lucifer (Mark Pellegrino) being set free from hell and appearing on Earth, and Sam and Dean learning that Castiel was killed by the archangels.